map of lpa boundaries with boundary for indicative wrz4w
map of lpa boundaries with boundary for indicative wrz4w

Insufficient Sustainable Water Supply

There is insufficient sustainable water supply to support further development in South East Water’s Water Resource Zone 4-West (WRZ4-W) without increasing existing supply risks and reliance on environmentally damaging abstraction.

The Environment Agency’s (EA) position statement, issued in September 2026, identifies a substantial supply-demand deficit affecting parts of Basingstoke and Deane, Hart and East Hampshire. Existing development already faces supply challenges, particularly in dry years; further growth will exacerbate these pressures. Capacity to accommodate medium- and long-term planned growth has not been demonstrated.

Scale of the shortage

South East Water (SEW) identifies baseline deficits of up to 19 megalitres per day (Ml/d) in a dry year and 7.3 Ml/d in a normal year for at least the next five years, against distribution input of approximately 50 Ml/d. These deficits assume closure of Greywell and reductions at Itchel to address environmental impacts. Even if Greywell and Itchel continue at the rates assumed in SEW’s appraisal and proposed reductions in customer levels of service are implemented, a dry-year deficit of 4.6 Ml/d remains unresolved. Proposed normal-year measures depend partly on continued damaging abstraction and do not establish a sustainable solution for growth.

Environmental constraints and delayed infrastructure

Abstraction at Greywell is damaging Greywell Fen Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) and preventing achievement of water-body environmental objectives; abstraction at Itchel is harming wet woodland and river flows. The EA has refused renewal of the Greywell licence, which SEW is appealing, and is considering reductions at Itchel. Increased abstraction at Lasham is unlikely to be viable without risking impacts on the River Itchen Special Area of Conservation (SAC).

Resolution of the full dry-year deficit currently depends on the Surrey Hills to Fleet pipeline within the Western Reinforcement Scheme. Although the 2024 round of Water Resources Management Plans (WRMP24) envisaged delivery in 2030–31, the statement records SEW’s informal indication of 2032 at the earliest, with delivery confidence uncertain. West Ham treatment improvements, expected by the end of 2026, would provide approximately 4 Ml/d in normal years but no dry-year benefit.

map of south downs national park authority boundary with indicative boundary for wrz4w
map of south downs national park authority boundary with indicative boundary for wrz4w

Implications for planning

The statement says WRMP24 growth assumptions and supply-demand assessments are no longer valid for planning growth. Local planning authorities should use updated SEW scenarios reviewed by the EA and undertake a comprehensive Water Cycle Study assessing cumulative demand, environmental effects and security of supply. Growth and, where proportionate, occupation should be aligned with delivery of adequate sustainable water capacity. The EA also strongly advises higher water-efficiency standards. It has objected to the Basingstoke and Deane Regulation 18 local plan consultation pending assessment demonstrating that growth will not harm the water environment and will allow statutory environmental objectives to be met.

Important qualification

This is not a blanket objection to every new development. Based on its assessment of approximately 2,200 homes awaiting determination or anticipated in applications over the next two years, the EA considers the additional demand proportionally small and is unlikely to object on water-related environmental grounds in the short term. This position is subject to review and does not remove security-of-supply risks or demonstrate capacity for wider growth. The central conclusion is that further medium- and long-term development cannot be assumed to have sufficient sustainable water available: updated evidence and a credible infrastructure delivery programme are essential.